Old requests would get buried, often replicated at different tiers, whether or not it's by the same user
The fact that it was a forum people could clutter it with literally anything, including stupid shit like religion, politics, LGBTQ+ bullshit, doom/trollposting, glownigger FBI pigshit posting CP, and the aforementioned screechbegging, and was often nuked out of either childish spite or for the safety, if one can call it that, for the site itself.
It was a 4chan dump inferno waiting to happen. I don't know why nobody bothered to see it coming.
I honestly believe a voting system for requests, much like the favorites system on the front page, would be/would've been better than the lazyslop forum route the admins went with.
Unfortunately, though, from what I could tell, it seemed the admins cared more about who THEY wanted imported more than anything, so any reasonable alternatives for a request option is often meet with a "go fuck yourself", "kill yourself", or one of the many other childish mannerisms they can vomit to keep their niche pornopoly running.
Both sides were children. Who knew?
Also, holy shit.
https://i.imgur.com/Yuohwyp.png